Merchant Place Books Logo

Resources

Who's really doing your books? 4 questions to ask any ecommerce bookkeeper

By Martin Elsworth, CPA, co-founder, Merchant Place Books

There is an old saying that a bad workman blames his tools. In bookkeeping, it's the software that's often the scapegoat for the workman's errors.

Short answer: most bookkeeping problems for online sellers are not caused by bad software. They come from not knowing who is actually doing the work, whether they know ecommerce, who is checking the work, and what happens when something is wrong.

Four questions will tell you more than any pricing, website or breezy marketing.

I am a CPA specializing in ecommerce, and this is what I would ask before handing anyone my books.

1. Who actually does my books; more importantly, how much ecommerce experience do they have?

Ask for names. Ask who is in your accounts day to day, what their credentials are, and how many Amazon or Shopify sellers they have worked with. The painful reality is that ecommerce accounting is different from generic business accounting in fundamental ways: payouts that bundle sales, fees, tax, refunds and reserves, inventory that has to be matched to what you sold, and sales tax that is not your revenue.

Someone learning those intricacies on your books is using your numbers as training wheels.

A good answer names real people, with the right credentials and hands-on ecommerce experience.

2. Who checks the work?

Everyone makes mistakes. What matters is whether anyone catches them before your CPA does, because by then the cost of correcting them does not come cheap, compounded on top of the time and stress of the back and forth.

Ask whether a second person reviews your books before they go out, or whether the person who prepared them is also the only person who checks them. Ask what the review covers: do they tie the payouts back to the bank, compare the month to the one before, look at anything that moved a lot, and go through the P&L, balance sheet and trial balance to sense-check the numbers?

A good answer describes a real review step by a named person, not "our software checks everything".

3. What happens if an error occurs?

The one question that separates firms most clearly, because it is the one few prepare for.

Ask how you report a problem, who responds, and how quickly. Ask whether corrected statements are reissued, and whether you pay anything for rectification if the mistake was theirs. Ask what happens to the months that were already delivered.

A good answer is a straightforward, stress-free process. If the answer is vague, the fix will be slow and land squarely on you.

4. What don't you do?

Everyone, bookkeeper included, has limits. The ones who say so plainly are easier to trust than the ones who have an eager yes to everything.

Common items that sit outside bookkeeping:

Some firms include some of these, some charge for them, and some do not do them at all. You want to know this at sign-up, not when a deadline arrives.

Ask too about volume. Many plans have order, revenue or channel limits. You should know what happens when you go over.

A good answer says plainly what is out of scope, and what it costs if you need it.

A few extra things worth checking

  1. Who owns your records? You should be the sole legal owner, with your data and history staying with you if you leave. This is sacrosanct. Non-negotiable. Period. The process for this handover should be simple, fast and easy.
  2. Do they need access to your bank accounts? No. Another non-negotiable. Working through your accounting software avoids it, with the bookkeeper only seeing the business transactions coming through the bank statement in the software. You stay in complete and sole control of your accounts.
  3. How do you cancel? Month-to-month with no cancellation fee is the cleanest answer. Long contracts are definitely a reason to ask more questions.
  4. Will they answer your CPA's or tax preparer's questions about their work, and at what cost?

How we do things at Merchant Place Books

  1. Who does the work. I am a CPA with 15 years in accounting and 6 in ecommerce, focused on Amazon and Shopify sellers (my LinkedIn). My co-founder, Chikuni Mutiswa, is a CFA, a QuickBooks ProAdvisor and a Certified A2X Expert (his LinkedIn). He sold online himself and ran a credit product that funded sellers' inventory before their settlements arrived, before he did the books for sellers. The day-to-day work is done by our team, working under the co-founders.
  2. Who checks it. A second pair of eyes on every set of books, on a maker-checker basis. Nothing goes out until a founder has reviewed it: work prepared by the team is reviewed by me or Chikuni, and if one of us prepared it, the other reviews it. The review ties payouts back to the bank, compares the month to the one before, looks at anything that moved a lot, and goes through the P&L, balance sheet and trial balance to sense-check the numbers.
  3. If an error occurs. Email us. We turn it around within 24 hours, and corrected statements are reissued at no fee.
  4. What we don't do. Bookkeeping, not tax filing, tax advice, payroll, sales tax filing or an audit. We track your sales tax exposure and calculate what you owe using your TaxJar account; registration and filing are handled by you or your CPA. Catch-up on past periods is a separate engagement. Our core specialisation is Amazon and Shopify; other platforms are case by case. Your plan is set by your revenue, orders and sales channels (limits are on the Pricing page). Revenue and orders are measured on a rolling 60-day average, so a seasonal spike or brief dip does not change anything. If you stay over your plan's limits for two consecutive cycles, we notify you and your next billing is at the new tier. If you add a sales channel your plan doesn't cover, we adjust your plan from the next billing date.

You are the sole recorded legal owner of all your accounting records and keep your data and history if you leave. We do not have access to your bank accounts; we work through QuickBooks. Plans are month-to-month with no cancellation fee, and we answer your CPA's or tax preparer's questions about our work at no extra charge.

Not sure whether we are the right fit? Book a discovery call, or start with the $95 Financial Diagnostic Review, which is credited to your first month.

More from Resources